|
Matt Smith -> RE: A Matter of Color... Skin Color - One Stop Thread (11/23/2007 10:56:26 PM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: zamdad quote:
Matt Smith For the record -- I see a lot of people repeating the same positions over and over again, from thread to thread. And I haven't seen much in the way of good old-fashioned listening to learn from the experiences of others... or from current research about the issue of race in American society. I've paid attention to the research, and I've had personal experiences. Racism's alive and well in American society. Not like it was 200 years ago, or 100, or 50 -- but very much an issue today as well. It's sad and discouraging to see people ignore or dismiss all the evidence that racism is a problem. And it's beneath us as a society. It's sad to see people offer brief prescriptions, based largely on the idea that they won't have to personally do anything about racism, and the problem lies with others. I think that's beneath us, too. I'll continue to post in solidarity and in hope. I'll continue to take personal responsibility, as a member of society, for the role I can play in dismantling racism. That's what I'd want others to do for me, if I were being treated unjustly. I have to agree with RC. Nice generalizing post. As I stated in my earlier post, we all come at this issue from personal experience. While we can educate ourselves and convince ourselves that we are experts, our personal experience regarding a given issue is going to be our guiding influence in how we percieve things. I'm curious, Matt, about your personal experiences with this issue. I know from perviosu conversations with you that you consider yurself a minority. We have another one stop thread for that topic. Since our experience shapes our worldview and most people on here are followers of Christ, I'm curious how you have experienced racism and what shpes your paradigm on this issue. With all due respect to both of you, I've posted specifics in other threads. (e.g. pages 5 and 6 of this one.) It would be nice if I'd gotten multiple replies to each of those posts, responding to the points I was making. But instead, they were largely ignored... and now I get multiple replies to my above post, criticizing me for not being more specific. Zamdad, RC, what should I make of that? I'm not sure which of my life experiences is shaping my views about racism. I think a couple experiences have been powerful: I was raised Jewish in a place with lots of ignorance, so I have a personal understanding of facing prejudice. I think this gives me a head start in trying to understand the experience of facing racial prejudice. And I have a strong commitment to fighting prejudice. There are lots of influences I can place into that Jewish context. "Lo alecha hamlachah lignor, v'lo atah ben chorin l'hibatel mimenah" - it's not up to you to fix the world yourself, but you're responsible for doing your part. I do believe strongly in right and wrong, and trying to make the world more right, and that we're all responsible for that. "They came for the Catholics, and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a Catholic..." Jews learned a while ago that in order to be safe, we all have to look out for each other and fight injustice together. This is the opposite of "Every man for himself" or "Oh well, we all have our challenges..." In my world, injustice is something to take very seriously. I also spent a long time learning about racism of my own accord. I asked questions, listened, read, and thought about it. I compared it to things I'd experienced. The more I learned, the more I can recognize racism when I see it -- because I know the context and history. And I realized there was lots of racism I saw growing up, but didn't recognize. Anyways. I could go on and on. I've had lots of experiences that may have shaped my perspective. But that's a start. Matt
|
|
|
|