|
PrexicKehdaki -> RE: Questions, questions, questions. (7/7/2008 10:49:41 PM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: SavedByGraceMD quote:
ORIGINAL: SavedByGraceMD Lets try this another way then. Joe Schmoe on the other side of the planet is a real living person. He leaves evidence to say it is so. You find the evidence, but have never seen Joe, so you don't believe he exists. But he is real, and the evidence proves it, but you never met him, so you deny his existence. You then try to make that evidence fit what you do know, because the evidence is there and it is undeniable. Make sense. No probably not. I was never one good at debating. I am too emotionally driven. quote:
It'd be more like, evidence exists for and against Joe Schmoe and I find the evidence against and the rebuttals of the evidence for.. more convincing. Ah, touche, or is it tuche, no, how do you spell this word, tooche, I do know this, but I am drawing a blank right now. Stupid spellcheck [:@]won't tell me the right spelling, what good is it.[;)] ^-^ It's touche. And if you wanna get real fancy, add the aigu accent mark over the e. :P quote:
ORIGINAL: SavedByGraceMD You aren't. My bad. But actively trying to denounce ones faith can be soon two ways. But I didn't mean it the way you think. It is your pride(that is atheists in general, not just you) that tells you, that you know more than God and more than a few billion other people. quote:
By definition I'm no where near as smart as God. The problem is, I don't think he exists in the first place.. so how does my pride have anything to do with God's intelligence? Also, I don't think I know more than a few billion other people. You're tagging on appeals to authority and appeals to populous with your appeal to emotions by using that. I'm not proud that I think differently than most people. YOU think differently than most people. MOST people aren't Christians. Is it your pride that is telling you you know more than a few billion other people and their gods? I don't think it is, so please don't think my pride influences my beliefs. Really, I have no pride. In fact, I have very little self esteem. lol I don't mean to offend you.[8|] lol, you didn't. Don't worry. quote:
ORIGINAL: SavedByGraceMD Well I did say, for me a threat of hell shows me a need for a savior. It is not circular, more like an arrow that points me to Him. Did it address your argument, maybe not, but that statement was on regards to a statement you made about fearing hell not being a good reason to believe. quote:
If the problem was trying to convince me of God with the threat of Hell, then I've explained why that doesn't logically work. So then claiming it points to my need for a savior.. kinda skips the "I need to be convinced of Hell first" part. Without trying to be repetitive, hell shows me the reason for a savior. For you who don't believe in either or, one can't force the need to be seen for the other without the other. For me it does, for you, not so much.[:D] Is Hell the reason you believe in Jesus and God in the first place? If not, then I lack that part and you have an advantage at being convinced by Hell :P If so, then if I can think of a scarier consequence than Hell, would you believe whatever I want you to believe? ^-^ quote:
ORIGINAL: SavedByGraceMD Well I never claimed to know anything about you. I only know what I read, and that verse is in regards to all people, not just you. No one will be without excuse come the day of judgment. I did offer for you to tell me your story so I can no better where you are coming from. quote:
I don't remember. Story of what? My disbelief? Whatever stories you would like to share. It is possible for you to come here for something other than arguing you know.[:'(]Like getting to know people, or coming back to your faith. [sm=thumbsup.gif] No you say, I had to try. You sure. The door is always open. Alright, I'll say a little about my disbelief. I usually end up regretting this.. 'cause people always take my personal details and run with it and try to psychoanalyze me and why I don't believe. But whatever.. I'll try to be brief. When I was 12, I started to become depressed. By 14, I was so depressed I tried to kill myself and I developed some self-injury habits. During this period, (I'm heavily medicated now by the way, lol, don't worry..), I started questioning life in general. I considered everything about my life and took nothing for granted. I mean.. honestly? You do a lot of thinking when you want to die.. religion just happened to find itself in the path of my inner struggling. I started researching religions, reading about them.. reading the Bible.. reading the Qu'ran. None of it made sense to me. The next part is going to take some maturity on everyone's part to not judge me as I'm just being honest. Ok, I think what really kicked me over the fence though.. was my encounter with a shock site. I read about "shock sites" in a reader's digest and I couldn't maintain my curiosity. I went to one, and watched a few videos that made me absolutely sick to my being. Not at the gruesomeness of it, but at the injustice of it. That this world was REALLY that bad at some times in some places. I wanted to cry and scream at the same time. I wanted to hurt the people that did these things to others. But there was a severe problem. The disease, the gore, the pain, the suffering, the emotional agony, the world.. a good bit of it had no guilty party. Who pays, who's to blame, for someone being crushed in an elevator? No one. Yet the Muslims, the Christians, the theists.. They had someone. At this point, the part of me that still believed in God wanted to curse God. I felt my existence couldn't be justified if I had no quarrel with a being that could help reduce the tears, but wouldn't, just to test our faith. I found it so petty of God. That he would go to such great lengths to let us suffer just to see who would make it out worshiping him. That many of those that felt the most extreme pains in their deaths, leaving scars for their families, would ultimately see no help from God.. but go to a place God himself allows.. a place for more suffering. I became the typical angry atheist. Over the course of years later. I grew calmer and refined my disbeliefs. I'm now personally in a state trying to understand religious faith.. which is a small reason I'm going to college to study psychology (mostly though because I want to help people who have dealt with severe clinical depression and self-injury and any other emotional distress). Ok, please don't take that and run. HOW I became an atheist is irrelevant to my atheism now. quote:
ORIGINAL: SavedByGraceMD I don't see it that way. There is no meaning to an atheists life, and have heard many say, "you live and you die, that is it". That my friend is meaningless. quote:
You're exaggerating the practicalities of that common phrase. Christians say it too. Not because they consciously believe life is meaningless, but because it expresses a state of desperation and pointlessness. Yes Christians do say, you live and you die, but I would wager[;)], that you wouldn't hear it followed up with, thats it. We all live, we all die, but for us, we know that is not it. As for atheists, I don't exaggerate when I am just repeating what I have heard many of them say. And it always ends with, thats it. You'd be surprised. I've discussed this on more atheist friendly boards.. how Christians at time seem oblivious of their belief in Heaven. They say things that sound like an atheist speaking.. yet simultaneously denying the possibility that there is no life after death. quote:
ORIGINAL: SavedByGraceMD quote:
For me, I find meaning in creating and learning. I read non-stop, I debate non-stop, I think non-stop. That gives me meaning. I find meaning in love, the unknown, and friendship. I find meaning in experiencing life. I find meaning in the fact that the atoms that make up my body have coalesced for such a brief time and will soon disorganize into my death. Huh, hear you go with that science mumbo jumbo again.[sm=yummy.gif], jj. I understand that you can find meaning in many places. The only difference in all that other stuff, is that it is fleeting. It is here today, gone in a NY minute. Love, friends, arguments, stuff, possessions, even the mind will all be gone one day. To me, that is meaningless, to you, maybe not. I do look for those things to, but I understand the fickleness of life, and nothing but the Lord can fulfill me now. Well, the point is moot considering I feel your meaning in God will also be gone one day. >.> lol quote:
ORIGINAL: SavedByGraceMD Why would Gods having a plan for your life depress you? 'Cause then I feel like I'm living his idea of my life and not mine. lol, it's just a weird feeling. quote:
ORIGINAL: SavedByGraceMD I hope you got some laughs out of this post. So you know, I do not enjoy arguing. hehe, I'm sure you all get laughs out of mine too. :P
|
|
|
|